V i s u a l C u l t u r e |
Reading: Give a reading of the extract from 'Mona Lisa' which explores the
representation of women in the changed world into which George has
emerged. Italian French What is a Reading? An A level Study by Mike Turner, May, 2000. |
Neil Jordan's 1986 hit movie 'Mona Lisa' examines the seedy underworld of 1980's London. The central protagonist, George (played by Bob Hoskins) guides the audience through a world of prostitution, crime bosses and violence as an ex-con who returns into a very different society. The world into which George and the audience is projected shows women - from a variety of classes and racial groups - with complexity and possessing varying levels of access to power.
The extract begins with George and his friend, Thomas (Robbie Coltrane), traveling to see George's ex-boss, Mortwell, who is revealed as the man for whom George served 7 years in prison. The old fashioned Jaguar car which George drives is an immediate indication of him being out of touch as he clearly looks out of place in the more modern London. Although the Jaguar is an older, classic car I feel Jordan uses it as a hyperbole, to exaggerate the time George has spent in prison.
It is made apparent during the conversation between Thomas and George that it is George's intention to return to the seedy underworld in which he used to earn a living, despite Thomas' warnings that times and Mortwell have changed. Strangely George is carrying a white rabbit as some kind of signal to his ex-employer, through which I think Jordan is suggesting that perhaps his film could have meanings on more than one level. I believe that the white rabbit references a meta-narrative relating to the Louis Carroll Novel 'Alice in Wonderland', in which the central protagonist, Alice, is led into an alternative world by a talking white rabbit. Here I think the rabbit is intended to symbolize George's transition from his previous life in prison into the seedy, criminal underworld. The fairytale meta-narratives are not exclusive to this section of the film and later, once the extract has ended further seemingly unrelated fairytale factors, like a large white horse and a group of dwarfs, further suggest that perhaps Jordan has included hidden meanings or ideology in the film.
As George enters the building in search of his ex-boss and a job, the audience is introduced to the first female in the extract and also the first from the criminal world (a fiery encounter between George and his ex-wife has already been shown). In a smoky atmosphere the woman is shown sitting at a bar. When George approaches she informs him that the bar is closed but, when George appears undeterred, she turns to a male worker for assurance assistance?. This immediately suggests that in the seemingly male exploited environment of a brothel (which the place is revealed to be) the females are still not in charge of their own business. It is almost as if the brothel produces men exploiting women exploiting men; it is a very male dominated environment in which females are shown as objects owned by the men.
In search of Mortwell, George is shown into an office and another of his ex-business partners. As he enters the office a computer can be heard beeping and, as the door is opened, a man is shown in the center of the screen tapping at the computer keyboard. Again this is a device used by Jordan to show Georges isolation from developing technology. The camera moves around as George enters the room and shows the screen from behind him. The lighting is used to again show this isolation as the computer is shown in the light through the single window whilst George remains in the shady corner, literally 'in the dark'.
After a brief confrontation between George and an employee of Mortwell, 'Dudley,' George is given a job as a driver and with it he is given a bleeper. The camera cuts to a dockland location and the home of Thomas, where George is staying. Thomas explains the functions and instructions for the bleeper, once again emphasizing the relationship (or lack of) between George and technology. This also establishes the relationship between George and the viewer as his bewilderment is amusing and identifiable likable?. As the camera cuts to inside the warehouse, in which Thomas' caravan is situated, the camera remains low to the floor and gives a medium close-up shot of a table covered with ornamental spaghetti. The living space is very dark and almost burrow like. Both men are very at ease in this masculine environment and in the back ground a single window has caged bars. This could suggest that George feels more at home in the secluded world of prison, the place he is used to, without the presence of females. As the friends move past the caravan a poster is seen of Mona-Lisa, an ironic touch by Jordan as the ideal face of femininity is shown in a masculine mechanics workshop in the manner of a pin-up.
In the next scene George attempts to make contact with his daughter after the unsuccessful attempt previously in the film. The scene begins with a point of view shot as George is parked outside a school as the pupils are being let out. There is a large wire fence with wooden stakes and barbwire between George and his daughter, showing the metaphorical barriers between them and the distance in their relationship. As the camera tracks the daughter it seems that her environment is dominated and controlled by males, like George's, as a football flies towards her head and she is forced to duck down. The camera briefly cuts to show George in the car to make the situation clear (i.e. that the audience is looking through George's eyes). George looks as if he is contemplating confronting her but the bleeper goes off and work separates George from his daughter. Being an ex-con and working in the criminal world are things that keep George from being a wholesome father, despite the fact that he is a decent man
In the next scene George looks starkly out of place at the high class hotel he is called to and the doorman stares at his shoes, denoting his difference in social class. Once George has entered the hotel, the audience is shown the first shot of Simone, the central female protagonist. She appears high up on a balcony in a point of view shot from George in an alluring and sexy dress. She is shot high up to emphasise her power, especially over George, her driver. The shot is very much like a scene from a fairytale presenting a Cinderella character standing in a magnificent, high-class building. Simone however does appear out of place amidst upper-class elites because?. There is then a reverse point of view shot and Simone looks down at her lower class driver.
George's innocence is shown again but rather than being with technology it is this time due to class difference as George unwittingly pockets his change instead of tipping the waiter. As Simone reaches the ground floor it is as if she has transformed back to a lower class prostitute and appears unglamorous in a long, dull coat. She is immediately approached by a disapproving hotel manager and asked to leave in no uncertain terms. The levels of society are mimicked physically as Simone joins working-class George from the higher balcony level and struggles to remain calm as she is escorted out of the hotel.
Once back at the car, Simone resumes her role as higher class and insults the ruffled George. When asked "where did they get you from?" George once again implies his innocence, replying 'Under a cabbage leaf". This remark again relates the film to a fairytale. Simones knowledge of higher class customs seems to give her some power over him. This theme continues as the pair embark on a car journey to Simone's next customer. In the scene Simone gets the majority of screen time in a series of close up shots. Jordan shoots the characters separately and they do not appear in the same shot for the entirety of the scene. This is done to emphasize their differences, both in class, race and gender.
Simone is shown as a woman between two classes. She obviously feels that she is George's social peer and yet is not welcomed into the upper classes due to her profession. She is differently depicted from the first woman of the extract, featured in the bar, as she is more in control and has authority over George. The audience learns that she doesn't work for a pimp and therefore the roles are reversed as she is exploiting men to make a living, rather than the other way around.
The camera cuts then to another high class hotel and again Jordan's portrayal of class differences is evident as George is unable to order a drink, ignored by a waiter. The scene has less to do than in the previous hotel and the pace is very quick, time is accelerated and Simone only stays what seems to be seconds. After a shot of the classic Jaguar in London, the camera cuts, again to a large stately house but this time George has to wait outside in the car. Music? His comment?
After a brief close-up shot of Simone, in which she instructs George to drive to King's Cross, the camera cuts to a point of view shot from George's perspective, as he again acts as a surrogate for the audience, gazing at the cheap, sleazy looking prostitutes and, like the audience, wondering why they have changed locations so drastically. The atmosphere is threatening and gloomy as prostitutes and pimps lining the roads shout and jeer at the expensive looking vehicle. The girls are colourful and exotic looking, perhaps like animals in a zoo, again Jordan portrays the lower class women as objects and sex as a business transaction, from which men make profit. In contrast, Simone is shown to be confident and in control at the low class King's Cross Road and the exclusive hotels alike. This is also in stark contrast to George who fails to fit in properly anywhere other than Thomas hanger in which he lives.
The final syntagma of the extract once again inforces more obvious abnormalities in the relationship between George and Simone. As the car pulls up to Simone's building the camera shows the pair in the same frame but still separated. Simone is sat in the back seat and on the opposite side. She reinforces her power over George as she attempts to give him money with which to buy clothes. Simone is depicted very differently to the street prostitutes in the previous scene. However, when George refuses the money she reacts more clinically: "I can claim it you know". Simone is acting like the males of the brothel and pimps of Kings Cross as she treats sex as a commodity. She is not kidding herself and is perhaps successful because of it. Her power is absolute as, even though George rejects the offered money, she gets her own way and shoves it into his pocket.
In conclusion the extract only really looks at three types of women and the scene in which George meets his daughter is brief and does not reveal a lot about their relationship or her character. The scenes in which Jordan contrasts Simone to her high class client and those in which she is contrasted against the street prostitutes are more enlightening. It seems that Simone is a powerful woman who seems to get her way around men and even uses them. She certainly has power over George but as the rest of the film reveals she is plagued by men in the criminal underworld and ultimately pays the price for isolating herself from them. ----- Perhaps you could say something here also about how Georges discovery symbolises the irony of women in Thatchers Britain of the 1980s being more powerful, yet also less powerful being commodified. Simone is taking advantage of the power offered by Thatchers rule, though this is dangerous. Finally the irony is that women have to be completely separated as symbolised by Simones real sexuality being lesbian?