V i s u a l C u l t u r e |
Reading: Explore the ways in which meta-narratives are suggested
by the selected extract from 'Leon' An A level Study by Emma Davies |
In this close reading from 'Leon', a Luc Besson film, meta-narratives will be uncovered
within the storyline, showing that these stories-within-stories give a depth of meaning to
the text. 'Leon' is a film about an Italian hitman of the same name and a young girl,
Matilda, who is suddenly orphaned when her parents are brutally murdered. Leon is
grudgingly thrown into parenthood as he is persuaded into taking Matilda in.
The extract chosen has five sections and mainly focuses on the development of Leon and
Matilda's relationship and their feelings for each other. They are about to move into an
apartment together and Matilda coerces Leon, against his better judgement, into letting
her into his world and teaching her the basic techniques of becoming an assassin. She, in
turn, promises to teach him how to read and write as a trade off. These two characters
then come to represent polarities; hers of learning and knowledge and his of primal
instinct.
In the first section this polarity is clearly demonstrated. The first frame of this scene
is a close up of Leon's hand opening the door to their new apartment. The viewer sees the
apartment for the first time through his eyes as he scans past Matilda, who is sitting at
a table writing. The camera then draws away from this view and follows Leon as he paces
the apartment like an animal searching its new territory for dangers. The non-diegetic
music has a regular military like beat adding to the atmosphere and tension. This music
which seems 'attached' to Leon then stops when his search is over and he slumps into an
armchair. Through all this Matilda is dealing with practical matters, filling out the
registration form for the apartment. She takes very little notice of Leon's activities,
which seem to occur on a more animalistic level to her train of thought.
The next part of this scene resembles a domestic melodrama as Matilda and Leon act out a
parody of a married couple jostling to assert their individual needs and finding levels.
Their positioning in the frame shows him sitting in a chair and her kneeling at his feet.
In this submissive pose she starts negotiating the terms of their relationship. The
strangeness is, that the subject matter of these negotiations is unconventional, as
Matilda is asking Leon to teach her his trade. He listens with a dominant air and seems
mildly irritated at her requests. He leaves her and the viewer hanging for his answer
while he suggests that he needs a drink. This reaction reinforces the analogy to
'coupledom' as he gives a cliched male response to problems with women; seeking answers at
the bottom of a glass. Matilda follows his lead, pandering to his request, as she tells
him to sit right there while she fetches the drink.
The editing to the next scene uses a thematic link as the viewer is shown a close up of
two glasses raised in salute, thus transporting the drink theme into this next section.
The scene has changed and Tony, Leon's employer and his 'bank', comes into the shot. The
frame is dominated by Tony's face and shot from over Leon's shoulder, creating the feeling
that Tony is in authority and control. As they are sitting in Tony's restaurant, a
case is brought to the table, which we find out carries a rifle. Tony indirectly answers
Matilda's request from the last scene, as he says to Leon 'I said to myself, Leon's a
pro., nobody uses that but beginners'. The way this answer is delivered makes the viewer
feel they have worked the answer out for themselves. Leon defends his request for this
'beginners' rifle, but gives nothing away about its true purpose.
Tony's dominance in the frames and dialogue of this scene create a feeling of his control
over Leon. Tony lectures Leon about the drawbacks of change. Leon takes on a submissive
and immature role as he eagerly listens and agrees with Tony, trying to please but
interestingly also trying to keep the truth from him. It seems that a father/son
relationship has developed here and that Freud's theories on childhood development,
particularly the Oedipal roles, could be used as a psychoanalytical framework for their
behaviour. Tony represents the Oedipal father figure, all be it a questionable one, and
Leon the son. Tony wants to control Leon and to take advantage of his simple disposition
and emotional immaturity. It suits him to keep Leon this way as he knows that he will be
more effective and focused in his work. Leon in turn has had no reason to cut these ties
with his father, thus keeping him in a state of immaturity, unable to break free of his
paternal bonds and move forward. However, it is established that Matilda's influence in
Leon's life has started to effect, even erode this Oedipal father/son bond, as Leon lies
to keep her existence in his life from Tony.
The fourth section again uses a thematic link as it cuts from Leon opening the gun case in
the restaurant, to it being opened in front of Matilda during her first 'lesson'. The
first frames of this scene are dominated by close ups of Matilda and Leon's faces, the
gun, and a brick wall they are crouching in front of. This creates a feeling of
confinement and makes a stark contrast as, having assembled the rifle, they both stand and
walk away from the wall. The scene suddenly opens out as the viewer is treated to a birds
eye view of the city skyline and a feeling of open space. The non-diegetic music adds to
this sense of new-found freedom as the slightly eastern influenced soundtrack crescendos.
They set up the rifle on the roof top and Leon's voice dominates the action as he carries
out a running commentary of instructions. There are several views through the site of the
rifle which transport the viewer to Matilda's perspective. She selects her practice
victim; a jogger who bears an uncanny resemblance to Clinton, with a entourage of
bodyguards. At this point the stories of two American Presidents are being drawn upon; the
Kennedy assassination and Clinton's famous jogging excursions.
As Matilda prepares for the shot, Leon's voice continues to instruct. The camera closes in
on Leon and Matilda's faces, with the site of the rifle between them like a third eye they
both share. The shots alternate from this, to the jogger, running in slow motion. The
effects of this and the camera panning in closer and closer on their faces with the music
building again, heightens the tension to a pitch. Suddenly, Leon breaks the spell, says
'now' the music stops, the shot is fired successfully and the jogger is hit in the chest
by a paint pellet. Matilda has accomplished the task with surprising competence and seems
to have found a sense of control that has been previously missing in her life. She then
shockingly but coldly asks if they can 'try with real bullets now'.
This time the music is used to link one scene to another. Bjork's hit, 'Venus as a Boy',
which is faded in as they walk away from the scene of the crime, carries into the fifth
scene. This scene reintroduces the domestic melodrama genre and is split into two
sections.
The first is almost entirely without dialogue and is dominated by Bjork's hit, that's
theme and words would seem to indicate a subconscious feeling Leon has for Matilda. It is
a montage of domestically motivated action shots, through which their developing
relationship is communicated. It captures the western culture of 'coupledom' showing her
cleaning, washing, shopping and him looking after his guns, and his plant (which perhaps
symbolises gardening) and exercising. The montage format gives the impression of the
passing of time as well as the development of their closeness. Proof of this closeness
comes during the portrayal of their exercise regime. Matilda starts off following Leon's
example and copying him, but after some difficulty in keeping up makes a silent bid for
independence. She is next shown following an aerobics workout on TV while Leon picks up
his regular regime. This meets with a resigned raising of the eyebrows from Leon. This
disapproval emphasises a distance between them that can only been borne out of their
new-found closeness.
During this part most shots of Leon are partial, as the camera focuses primarily on
Matilda. However, Leon's dominance and his 'provider's status is felt as he instructs her
in her non-conventional (assembling and cleaning guns) and conventional 'chores'. Suddenly
the roles are reversed. Leon is in the forefront of the frame with his head bowed over a
desk in a submissive, almost school boy pose. Matilda is only partially in the shot as she
paces up and down behind him like a school teacher reading from a book of Socrates. This
is an interesting touch as Socrates was the 'father' of Western philosophy which again
reinforces Matilda's 'knowledge and learning' representation in the polarity stakes.
In the second part of this fifth section, Matilda, having had enough the 'dutiful wife'
act, suggests that they play a game. Leon reluctantly agrees and her suppressed childlike
enthusiasm comes to the fore as she bounces into the bedroom to change. The game she
chooses involves dressing up which is somewhat symbolic of Matilda's lost childhood. She
then carries out Hollywood icon impressions: Madonna, singing 'Like a Virgin'; Marilyn
Monroe, singing 'Happy Birthday'; Charlie Chaplain and Gene Kelly. It is difficult to
divorce Matilda entirely from these characters at this point, as they could be seen to
represent her secret desire to attain some of their attributes. Leon shows ignorance in
his inability to recognise any of these famous icons, even though they span the Hollywood
era. This exaggerates his narrow existence and 'loner' life style. He then, successfully
guesses Matilda's Gene Kelly impersonation and displays a childlike excitement which links
a reaction in a scene at the beginning of the film, where he watches 'Singing in the Rain'
in a cinema.
Leon then attempts a convincing impression of John Wayne. This is an interesting choice as
John Wayne himself portrayed the archetypal 'loner' in most of his films. Matilda then
struggles with the answer and Leon retreats defeated and upset. Matilda tries to placate
him and displays a longing in her voice as she describes him as 'amazing'. Through this
and her flirty impersonations of Madonna and Marilyn, it is obvious that Matilda has deep
sexual feelings for Leon. Leon's reaction to this 12 year old girl's advances is one of
discomfort and embarrassment. This unconventional love between an older man and a young
girl raises many issues linked to paedophilia. However, Leon constantly squashes any
advances Matilda makes and keeps this potentially explosive issue in check. Links could be
made here to such films as Andrew Lyne's 'Lolita' which more controversially deals with
the subject of paedophilia head on.
The scene ends with Matilda placing Leon's beloved plant, which he describes earlier as
his friend, out on the windowsill of their apartment for its daily dose of sunlight. She
stares at it longingly, for it now becomes her secret representation of Leon to which she
can show her true feelings.
This reading has demonstrated how embedding and developing meta-narratives in a text
produces a depth and richness to a story line and its characters. During this short
extract the domestic melodrama genre has been used, along with Tony and Leon's Oedipal
father/son relationship; the stories of two American presidents and the story of
Hollywood. Through their use the characters become believable and gain credibility and
motives for their actions. The viewer is drawn successfully and convincingly into their
world.
Emma Davies. December, 1999.